The Star Wars prequel trilogy has gained a notorious reputation as one of the most underwhelming and frustrating installments in the beloved franchise. Its many detractors have taken to the internet to voice their numerous complaints, pointing out everything from poor storytelling choices to questionable visual effects. Despite the multitude of criticisms, it’s possible that just a handful of key alterations could have vastly improved the trilogy’s standing among audiences. By making a few crucial tweaks, the prequel trilogy could have easily avoided much of the backlash it received. (Also read: Watch: Top performances from The Voice Season 22)
Star Wars is a science fiction franchise created by filmmaker George Lucas. The series has a vast universe and takes place in various planets and galaxies, following the adventures of iconic characters such as Luke Skywalker, Princess Leia, Han Solo, and Darth Vader. The franchise began with the release of the original film Star Wars (later retitled A New Hope) in 1977, which was followed by two sequels, The Empire Strikes Back (1980) and Return of the Jedi (1983).
Here’s potential changes that could have had a significant impact on the films’ overall quality and reception. By exploring these potential modifications, it’s clear that the prequel trilogy had the potential to be a much more successful and satisfying addition to the Star Wars universe.
George Lucas excels at directing but struggles with writing dialogue, as seen in the Star Wars prequel trilogy. Despite his involvement in all aspects of production, including writing, the trilogy suffers from wooden and cringe-worthy dialogue that fails to deliver. A dedicated writer could have greatly improved the political dialogue, which felt flat and unconvincing. The trilogy relied heavily on dialogue to advance the plot, but missed opportunities for meaningful character development, with crucial moments told rather than shown. The prequel trilogy’s dialogue needs significant improvement, and greater emphasis on the writing process would have greatly benefited the films.
2. The prequel series had the potential to expand the Star Wars universe, but fell short due to the lack of world-building. Despite the vastness of the galaxy, the trilogy revisited the same planets repeatedly, failing to explore new ones. This limited exploration hindered the audience’s engagement and imagination. With a greater focus on world-building and exploring the mechanics of the universe, the trilogy could have been far more compelling.
3. The prequels had an excess of political dialogue and characters sitting around, with everyone seemingly engaged in politics, be it the Galactic Senate or the Jedi Council. While not necessarily a bad thing, these scenes often dragged on without a clear purpose. Unlike Star Trek, where political dialogue debates moral dilemmas with exciting consequences or thought-provoking outcomes, Star Wars’ political dialogue mostly serves as exposition or connects scenes together.
The Star Wars franchise also includes spin-off films, television shows, books, comics, and video games, making it one of the most expansive and lucrative media franchises of all time. The series has had a significant impact on popular culture, and its themes and characters have become ubiquitous in modern society.